The Hunger Games: A Romantic Analysis of the Peeta vs Gale "Love Triangle" | HobbyLark
One interesting aspect of Peeta and Katniss' relationship is the evolution. The two start off as Kat Li, Quora Marketing Analyst. No. Katniss. Mason is a full service public relations and branding agency, so we The story is about Katniss Everdeen and Peeta Mellark, 16 year olds from District short of the brand promise, the brand marketing efforts will backfire. Team Gale. The Hunger Games Peeta Mellark, Gale Hawthorne, Katniss Everdeen. Relationships: Peeta Mellark and Katniss Everdeen.
She had to grow up fast and had no one to take care of her or love her unconditionally To Katniss, Peeta steps into the parent role.
When they're not on good terms, what she misses the most about him are his strong arms at night, chasing away her nightmares Whenever she is facing some obstacle and feels weak or powerless i. At the end of the day, I think there's enough evidence to make a good case for Katniss's not being in love with Peeta. Yes, she appreciates his good qualities, she cares for him, and ends up marrying him, but it's not out of a unconditional romantic love.
- Katniss Everdeen's Relationships in "The Hunger Games"
- Does Katniss Truly Love Peeta?
- The Hunger Games: A Romantic Analysis of the Peeta vs Gale "Love Triangle"
I love the two diametrically opposed answers from Cristina Hartmann and Kat Li, and I think they both have merit, but I'm a big Bill Clinton fan, so I'm going to present a Third Path sorry, something I read like in the last 24 hours, verbal slippage. First, I think it's pertinent to point out that the above mentioned answers are considering "love" in a certain context, as a feeling of romantic attachment and affection. I would argue that love is a choice, an action, rather than an emotional reaction.
That to love, one chooses to stand by another, through thick and thin, and chooses to devote oneself to the other, regardless of what they may feel. So, if we consider love as an action, as opposed to a feeling, then first and foremost, the answer to this question would be yes.
But I'm going to delve a little further. Katniss is far from a passive character. She acts, and she survives, but when she acts, is she being reactive or proactive?
I believe that there are two true proactive actions taken by Katniss. One is assassinating the President Coin, the other is choosing to love Peeta at the resolution of the three novels. During the first novel, The Hunger Games, Katniss reacts to everything. She reacts when her sister's name is called, by standing up and taking her place.
She reacts in the games in order to survive. She reacts to the hints that Haymitch sends in regards to how she should act towards Peeta, creating a false romance in order to save them both.
She acts, but it is reactive. During the second novel, Catching Fire, again she is reactive. She is reacting to the mess that she feels she created at the end of The Hunger Games. She reacts to the different dangers faced during the games.
Another way to point out her reactive nature is shown in the fact that she is not let in on the plot to escape the second Games. She does not know that there will be an escape attempt. She is still along for the ride. This is thematic in the first two novels. During the third novel, she begins to be proactive. I stated that there were only two proactive actions I could point to earlier in this answer, but you could argue that her decision to don the mantel of the Mockingjay in the third novel, Mockingjay, is also a proactive decision.
I do not feel that it was because there was a large push in that novel to make sure that you knew that she felt she did not have a choice.
But she did have a choice in how she would act as Mockingjay. Still, in general, I think that is a reactive as opposed to a proactive stance.
Once, she enters the capital, she in many ways does become proactive, but is still reacting to the dangers around her. Nonetheless, by this time she has taken some control over her destiny and her essential character has changed from a reactive to a proactive character.
Finally, she assassinates President Coin -- reactive or proactive? I will argue proactive. I do not believe she killed Coin because of her sister's death, for two reasons - 1 she could never be sure it was Coin who ordered the actions resulting in her sister's death and 2 the lack of emotion she displayed when she killed Coin. I believe that after two weeks or however long it was of the new Presidency, she saw enough to make her decide that Coin was no better than Snow.
She knew Snow would die regardless, but she knew she was the only one who would have the opportunity to kill Coin, so she proactively decided to do just that. Now, the heart of the argument or is it the argument of the heart?katniss & peeta II loving you forever, can't be wrong
If you wish to avoid spoilers, please skip this article! This article is an exploration of the relationships that Katniss maintains with the people in her life. Its purpose is to underscore the very human interactions throughout the novels in the hopes of bringing Katniss's own personality more fully into light. Originally, this article started out as a mind-map, the intention of which was to help determine personality traits significant to the story of The Hunger Games.
In order to fully understand Katniss, you must understand her relationships. Hopefully following this article, you'll have a better understanding of who she is through her relationships with other people in the books. Source Who Is Katniss Everdeen?
The answer to this question seems to differ depending on who you ask. Some people feel that she is. There are readers who believe that she is a weak heroine with no strength to change the world she lived in. To take the most sensible route to answer this question, Katniss is the heroine of The Hunger Games trilogy. She is the girl on fire who volunteered to save her sister's life when the twelve year-old was reaped in The Hunger Games. She is an archer and a hunter, a provider and a sister.
To some, she is a friend, and to others, she is the girl who sings. Many people love Katniss, and just as many people hate her for a number of reasons. Far from perfect, she's not your typical teen hero. Some people argue that Katniss is two-dimensional.
You'll have the opportunity to give your point of view. As for me, I believe that Katniss is one of the most dynamic females in young adult fiction among those novels I've read and I hope that through these pages I can convince you of the same. If you haven't read the series yet, this is a good time to purchase it. The hardcover boxed set is available to the right if you think that you're going to enjoy the series.
Otherwise, it's less expensive to purchase on Kindle. The hardcover set is nice to have for those who enjoy The Hunger Games, however, and it is recommended.
Does Katniss Truly Love Peeta? | HuffPost
Katniss reassures Prim before the Reaping. This was a key turning point for Katniss, because without it, she may not have become the adolescent she is throughout the novels. Her love for Prim is obvious both in the novels and in the films.
Everyone who has seen the movie trailers knows the line "I volunteer! I volunteer as tribute! Later, when Prim comes to say goodbye to Katniss in the Justice Building, she tells Katniss that she has to win and come back to District Twelve.
Though she believes there is no hope of her returning home, Katniss promises Prim that she's coming home, and later informs Caesar Flickerman that she's going to try. When she's in the Arena, Katniss begins to see her sister, Prim, in a twelve year-old tribute named Rue, who she vows to protect in the Arena as much as she can.
It is because of her love for Prim that Katniss loves Rue and goes great lengths to attempt to protect her. Everdeen checks Katniss out in the mirror before the 74th Reaping.
Everdeen deserve Katniss's hatred? She abandoned her family when she became too depressed to look after them. Yes, but only temporarily. Katniss should have forgiven her when she recovered. It's natural for a woman to retreat emotionally when her husband dies.
Katniss Everdeen and Peeta Mellark: A Realistic "Love Story"
It wasn't her fault. He is both a physical danger and psychological influence to her as on top of trying to kill her, he lowers her mental health by causing her to make decisions and judgments based on the guilt she feels instead of what she wants and needs and by making her feel low and lower than she already feels at various parts in Mockingjay. Peeta's impact on Katniss' mental state is highlighted where Katniss expresses "All those months of taking for granted that Peeta thought I was wonderful are over.
Finally, he can see me for who I really am. And I hate him for it. Peeta makes her feel bad about herself and makes her feel guilty, and Peeta's return did not entirely mean a romantic rekindling for Katniss. She tries to deal with her conflicting emotions for Peeta and for her situation with him by avoiding him, and when she cannot avoid him her encounters with him are filled with hostility. But she is not allowed to deal with her conflicting emotions without having more guilt placed on her plate.
Now, I'm not saying you shouldn't have a fully loaded weapon next to you round the clock. But I think it's time you flipped this little scenario in your head. If you'd been taken by the Capitol, and hijacked, and then tried to kill Peeta, is this the way he would be treating you? It isn't how he would be treating me at all.
He would be trying to get me back at any cost. Not shutting me out, abandoning me, greeting me with hostility at every turn. Or do they treat them with hostility and act against them? Katniss does both but then is reproached and chastised with no regard for her wants and needs.
The implied message here is that Katniss should do for Peeta what he would do for her but after Katniss saves Peeta she does not do this. The question is why? Could it possibly be because she does not want to? Could it be because she has reasons or reservations that distance her from him?
Haymitch claims that Katniss is "punishing [Peeta] over and over for things that are out of his control" but when looked at closely is that really what Katniss is doing?
Katniss is presented with a predicament that she never comes to work through. She wants to pursue a relationship with Gale but cannot do so without having psychological and emotional ties to Peeta with who she first came to associate romantic actions and feelings with and with who she now psychologically and physically associates safety and security with. This is combined with her feeling responsible for Peeta and combined with the fact that she now has feelings for Peeta.
But these romantic actions and their resulting feelings and development came while she was being controlled and manipulated, and they are also surrounded in trauma.
She also cannot pursue a relationship with Gale without being judged, reproached, and "guilt-tripped" combined with the fact that she is no longer the Katniss she used to be.
Yet while she longs for Peeta, she does not necessarily want to be in a relationship with him or never makes it clear that she does. Her thoughts of him relate to what he makes her feel, what she came to associate with him i. Katniss' abandonment of Peeta after she works to save him from the Capitol is a form of releasing herself from the role that she had been given and a form of releasing herself from the responsibilities that came with that role, as well as a way of protecting herself from the now-dangerous Peeta.
Her behavior shutting him out, abandoning him, and treating him with hostility at every turn was one of the only ways she had left to her to communicate to Peeta and to others that she did not want to be in a relationship with Peeta or at least that she needed some space from him. She wants Peeta to live, be safe, and she cares about his well-being as supported by her joining the rebellion to save him and as is supported by her guilt and complicated feelings throughout the story. She cares for him as indicated by her inner dialogue.
We do not get to see her process this realization but can piece it together based upon her earlier decision to be with Gale and her pursuing an unofficial relationship with Gale i. Katniss is not allowed to not want to be in a relationship with Peeta or is not allowed space from Peeta to sort out her wants and needs because of all that he has done for her and because of all that he has been through. So Katniss finds herself trapped and manipulated once more.
Who was Katniss' true match?
Katniss Everdeen's Relationships in "The Hunger Games" | HobbyLark
Peeta Mellark Both of them were equal matches for Katniss. Neither of them were matches for Katniss. Katniss is an acceptable match for Gale and Peeta because both Gale and Peeta have seen or come to see Katniss for who and what she is and have found traits that they want in a partner and are more than happy to take Katniss as she is.
And while Gale and Peeta have had the opportunity to make this assessment about Katniss and to determine that she would be a worthwhile companion, Katniss has not been able to make this assessment for herself and has not even allowed herself to venture emotionally, mentally, or physically into that territory due to her circumstances, life experience, and how she views life. Even the time she tries to give herself to work through her emotions is taken away from her by Haymitch, those that reproach her, and the war.
Neither Gale nor Peeta match Katniss' spirit, her view of life, or what she wants. Gale wants to change the current world in which they live and does not accept the world in which they live, Peeta hopes for a future in the world that exists, while Katniss wants to survive and get through life.
Both Gale and Peeta want Katniss but neither one of them take into account what Katniss wants and most of the time Katniss does not even get to take into account what she wants because what she wants and what little she knows that she wants is constantly manipulated and threatened by forces outside of her control and by the people in her life.
In addition, it can be argued that both Gale and Peeta have an agenda when it comes to Katniss. Gale is removed from the ending after his indirect involvement in Prim's death but prior to this Katniss was faced with the decision of changing and being with the guy that she cared for and wanted to be with or staying the same and being with the guy that she cared for but did not completely want to be with.
Or to be with either of them and in so choosing to be with a guy focused on his own needs over hers based upon Gale and Peeta's discussion over who Katniss will "choose.
She also never has to work through her complicated feelings regarding each of them and regarding herself.